Transcript: Zinzi Clemmons [Francesca] Zinzi Clemmons, welcome to Writer's Voice. Thanks for having me. This is a wonderful series of essays, Freedom. In the series, you reclaim the word freedom, I think, from the narrow idea that it means simply being left alone to do whatever you want. You draw in Orlando Patterson, and I'm going to ask you to tell our audience who he is, and you distinguish between personal freedom, the freedom to pursue our desires, and civic freedom. So first, tell us who Orlando Patterson is, what did he mean for you in writing these essays, and what does freedom mean to you? [Zinzi] So, freedom as a title came from an essay that's included in the book. And that essay is, it's on a topic that I've written about, you know, since the beginning, which is South Africa, my personal experience in South Africa over the past 40 years, my family's history there. And naturally, because of the time that I've been there and traveled there, a lot of it has to do with the country's independent struggle from colonial rule. So that essay talks about that, it talks about the few years post-independence, and some of the political battles, briefly, political struggles that have happened. And it also talks about, it reflects on Nelson Mandela's death, on the event of his death, as I was there at the same time that my mother died a year on from her death, and I was kind of reflecting on her passing. So that essay, it ended up being about two forms of freedom, the sort of personal freedom that I had found myself in after having lost one of my parents, who was like a very dominant figure in my life, at a relatively young age of, you know, 26. And then also the South African national struggle for freedom from apartheid. And then, you know, in that period, the sort of post-colonial struggles of nation-making and how the country would address the needs of all of its citizens of all races. And it started from that idea, and I started to think more directly and explicitly about the concept of freedom. You know, I was writing the author's note and kind of putting the book together at a moment where we were in, like, Trump II, and obviously this, hopefully, nature of the far right in the United States, and Charlie Kirk was murdered, and he was famously murdered wearing that shirt that said freedom on it. And it, you know, has just been a slogan of the far right and this kind of pig-headed idea that people who are the most free, probably in history, somehow need more freedom to do whatever shitty things that they wish at all times. But really, it just entails subjugating other people and making other people feel less free. And so, I was sort of trying to, like, intellectually square that idea with the legacy of freedom that, as I had always known it, first from being a child of a South African mother, was very proud and part of their freedom struggle. And also, as a student of African American and African letters, and the person of the Black diaspora, who had read, who has read, you know, many generations of literature from Black people, and similar literature from other freedom movements. Orlando Patterson is a Harvard sociologist. His work has more recently been identified with the discourse of Afro-pessimism, which is sort of, you know, more popular and sort of bled into the mainstream in all sorts of ways. But he has written a lot on slavery, the conditions of slavery, and also the condition of freedom. And one of the most important theses of that work that I cite, which is freedom in the making of Western society, is the idea that the people who were able to imagine and theorize freedom most clearly and most consistently were slaves. And he linked the idea of freedom with the condition of slavery, people without freedom, which is a complete and total rebuke of the philosophy that the far right puts forward, right? And so that was a moment where I could link all of these various ideas together, and was able to think of them in that intersection. [Francesca] You know, the far right seems to think about freedom in almost like it's in its libertarian sense. I have the freedom to do whatever I want, no matter how that affects anybody else. But I think you really argue in this essay, just, you know, as a conclusion that one comes to, is that my freedom really can't be separated from your freedom. Would you like to say something about that? [Zinzi] I mean, you know, that moment in the essay comes from observation, anecdote of how I've lived my life and, and this various things that I've, you know, seen around me. You know, we're in a moment where people are wondering a little bit more openly about these things. And they're coming to a head, but it's just so obvious at this moment, and I think increasingly obvious to other people. And, you know, possibly stems from this idea of, who are we, right, which is something that I investigate through, through prose and in sort of a technical manner. In the first short essay of the book, I wrote an essay that is narrated in the first person plural, the we, right. And I'm sort of narrating like the major experiences, the major sort of political events of my generation in this country, 9-11, the Iraq war, recession, COVID. And in that essay, I had to think about who we is, like, I'm writing in this we voice, who does that include? Who does it not include? And at the risk of being reductive, you know, I think that's the question that we're all being forced to reckon with in this moment is, who is the we in America? And the problem of freedom for the far right, or perhaps their delight, they would say, is that they've just narrowed that we very small, but we're in a moment where, as a country, we're being forced to consider, you know, who are we who has rights? And who has the right to speak, who has the right to be represented, who has the right to to enjoy safety and security and prosperity in a way that we haven't really quite before, or in a different way than we have before. Perhaps that's, that's more accurate. [Francesca] Yeah. And we'll get back to that as well. But I want to come back to your mother, because you just said the word, was it safety or security? She kind of presents one of the contradictions in a way between freedom and security. You have a epigraph, I guess you'd call it, by Stephen Biko, who was, of course, a great freedom fighter who was murdered by the apartheid regime. The most potent weapon in the hands of the oppressor is the mind of the oppressed. If one is free at heart, no man-made chains can bind one to servitude. And that's both a political statement. It's also a personal statement. So your mother was a freedom fighter. And she, as you said, she gave you one of the book's earliest lessons in the contradictions of freedom, because her protectiveness constrained you. But after her death, you began to understand the dangers that produced that protectiveness, that need for security. So tell us a little bit about her and about this, you know, contradiction, which it seems often people are seeking to constrain the liberty of others, because they are concerned about their own security. And they mistakenly think their security is bound up in the lack of freedom of others. [Zinzi] Yeah, so my mother, to give a little context, she came to the United States from South Africa in the 80s. Up until that point, she had been a student activist at the University of the Cape and then Wits University in Johannesburg, organizing apartheid against the government at that time. She was getting increasingly involved in some more dangerous activities. When she met my father, she was in Botswana. He was there volunteering. And she was there to pick up literature that she would later be smuggling into the country that had been banned. And something that I learned later, many years after she'd passed, is that my grandfather had actually called my father after my mother and my father had met, because they met at that time, then my father came back to the United States. And my grandfather called my father and basically begged him to let my mother move to the United States with him, because he was very afraid that she would get herself killed. And, you know, later, again, found out many years on that she had been one of the most wanted student activists in the country. And it's important that I learned these things after she had died, because I never had a full picture of who she was in her youth, both how involved she was politically and also how kind of wild she was. And that's an example, an illustration of the kind of protectiveness that my parents sort of constructed for us. When she came to the United States, a number of changes happened that I think can be sort of common for immigrants, particularly to this country, the pressure to assimilate is quite huge. And especially, you know, as a Black woman. And I think she ended up regretting some of her actions in the past, or just it's probably some sort of PTSD, survivor's guilt, there was something very complex that happened when she moved here. And it made her, I think, somewhat ashamed of her past, and partly very afraid of it. And when I was growing up, I was sort of naturally rebellious. And I was very outspoken. And my mother and I were always at odds. And I could never quite understand where it came from. It always just seemed to be naturally that way. And as I got older, and was sort of able to observe her as a very young adult, she passed when I was a young adult. You know, I started to understand that she was motivated by fear. I understand that, understood that even better after she passed away. And, you know, now that I'm a parent, I understand it in a completely new dimension. You know, to be honest, it's something that I find myself thinking about and sort of fighting through as I age. You know, the tendency is to become more protective for most people. What I try and keep in mind and keep in balance and to teach my students is to always try and mitigate those impulses to cause harm to other people. I think a lot about the criminal justice system. That's sort of been another preoccupation of mine sort of later in life, in my mid age, wherever the hell I am. But, you know, I think as somebody, you know, who was involved in the Me Too movement, I think a lot about what justice should look like. I wrote in the book about a good friend of mine from childhood who was a victim of gun violence. I think a lot about, you know, what justice should look like, can look like for his family. And trying to balance justice with mercy is not an easy task, but I think that's the entire terrain. [Francesca] And say more about that justice and mercy. [Zinzi] Well, I'm thinking specifically about violent crime, victims of violent crime. You know, that's something that I lived with, my family lives with a lot in South Africa. And I always I always felt myself walking a line because of my specific privilege. My family is a mixed race, they're colored in South Africa. They're not what is considered Black over there, which until independence had been the lowest caste in society. And we were given, you know, certain number more rights than Black people, deliberately to, you know, keep us at odds. And my family, we've been middle class, both sides. And because of that, I've always recognized, you know, that when there have been situations where, you know, I've encountered violence, or the times that we've been robbed, just happened many times. You know, there are people on both sides of a crime. And both sides are owed something. And I think both are important. Particularly in South Africa, so many victims of violent crime are Black, are very poor. That's something that I always had to, that I always observed. And I think that there is a balance where people can live in safety. And people who offend, don't have their lives thrown away and disposed of. And I think that's highly important. [Francesca] So you mentioned your childhood friend, that essay is Chasing Robbie. And in there, I think you're talking about, you know, if we want to think through the lens of freedom, and lack thereof, you write about segregation. And how segregation, both in housing and education, invisibly circumscribed your childhood and his. Yet your parents were able to find a way toward a privileged education for you, comparatively speaking to Robbie's. How did your experience differ from Robbie's? And what did it share with his, in the sense of that invisible circumscribing of both of you by segregation? [Zinzi] Yeah, so Robbie was a friend of mine from the third grade when I entered school in the Wallingford-Swathmore School District in Pennsylvania. We were two of three Black children in my third grade class. Wallingford-Swathmore is a majority white public school district in a suburb of Pennsylvania. It's a very high achieving school district. And it's, you know, there are a variety of communities that the school district draws on, but many of them are affluent, upper middle class. And the school district, because of that, is well funded. My family and I had moved from a school district a few miles away, but still in the same county, William Penn, which was majority Black. It was underfunded, and it was one of the lower performing public school districts. My family decided to move us to Wallingford-Swathmore, just entirely for the access to that quality education. And something that I found out later on was that, you know, a lot of other families had essentially made the same decision. And a lot of Black families, in particular, had made arrangements to send their children to the school district that were sometimes, you know, illegal. Sometimes they had sent their children to live with relatives, so that they could be considered, you know, legally able to go to the schools. And that actually described a lot of the Black families that were in that district at the time that I was there. So Robbie was from the nearby city of Chester, which is, you know, the mirror inverse of Wallingford-Swathmore. And Chester is, it's a city that's right on the Delaware River, right across from Wilmington. And it used to be an industrial hub. A lot of shipping companies were there. And it fell into a pattern of decline that is similar to a lot of Rust Belt cities. Basically, you know, industrial collapse, white flight, urban blight, segregation. And now, Chester is still highly impoverished. It's, you know, widely considered one of the worst sites of environmental racism in the United States. It's the home of a huge incinerator plant that frequently causes the air to smell badly, quite noticeably. [Francesca] Robbie, because he wasn't in the district, so-called legally, he had to leave and go back to Chester. Is that right? [Zinzi] No, he didn't. Because he was basically adopted by his aunt and uncle. But I interviewed another classmate who, you know, their family went through, did a lot of maneuvering around the system to try and to make sure that they could enroll in the district. So Robbie, Robbie came from this community, and we went through school together. After graduation and after college, he moved back to Chester and was working in the high school. Specifically because he, you know, he wanted to give back to a lot of children like him. And during that time, he was gunned down in a random act of violence. It's still officially unsolved. And, you know, that has been the case for many years in Chester. They have had a very low clearance rate of murders in the city. And because of that, I had to kind of make sense of his death in another way, which is how I started to write about it. Because it never felt like there was closure in a legal sense. And what I ended up doing was, you know, talking to a lot of people I grew up with and doing a lot of research into the history of the two areas. You know, where we grew up is Swarthmore, and the surrounding areas in Willingford-Swarthmore School District. And Chester, Pennsylvania, you know, the two places are separated by a few miles, but they could not be more different. And I started, you know, just really thinking about how a situation like that occurs. And what I found is that, you know, the school district is a part of that. The white flight that happened is a part of that. And Black families from Chester not being allowed through restrictive housing codes and other sort of extra legal means, not being allowed to settle in those other white areas, that created, you know, a city in Chester that is devoid of a lot of resources and attention. And it's become a segregated Black city, like so many in our region and in the country. [Francesca] And is that the justice and the mercy part that you spoke of before? An understanding of how institutions create segregation, which limits the freedom of certain people to, and in this case, Black people, to have a life of true choice. And so, that leads to, in other words, how crime grows out of a lack of freedom to some degree. [Zinzi] Yes. You know, I've thought a lot about the person who murdered my friend. Again, I've been, you know, the victim of violence myself. And it's given me very little satisfaction to think about justice in the way that we tend to conceive of it. I mean, you know, I'm far from the first person to think about this. I think it's been really heartbreaking to see some of the direction of national local politics since 2020, where we had a moment in this country where people were thinking about abolition and were thinking about defunding police. And it's kind of become, you know, consensus, at least among like, certain political class to say, you know, those things were really foolish and we were overshooting. [Francesca] Yeah, even AOC, who talks about woke one, and we went a little extreme. I remember, you know, when that happened. I mean, like you, I had a moment of real hope when I saw that there was in 2020, so many people, you know, I live in a very white area, East Hampton, New York, you know, which actually has a lot of poverty in it, but people never associate it with poverty. But, you know, when I saw so many people who were acting in solidarity and coming out and actually risking what we thought might have been our lives to come out, because it was in the middle of COVID, in support of solidarity and heard that people were talking about defunding the police. And I was, I remember thinking to myself, I could hardly believe that people were able to finally wrap their minds around the idea that the police was not the answer to the kinds of conditions that create crime. And to see that go back in the way you talk about it as well in this book, Zinzi Clemens and Freedom, you know, it's been heartbreaking. Yeah, absolutely. [Zinzi] And, you know, I do believe that things will progress. I guess I have to believe that. I think changes have been made, minds have been changed. And I think I have to believe that it will show up in the future in some way. But yeah, I oftentimes just want to shake people who are going back on some of those things from before and we can do better. [Francesca] Well, let's talk about how you interrogate the notion of Afro-pessimism, which you mentioned before in relationship with Orlando Patterson. I want to bring in another limit to freedom, which you also talk about in the chapter about Mandela and your mother, in that freedom chapter, which is that once the apartheid regime was defeated and people theoretically gained their freedom, that freedom was circumscribed by the fact that the institutions of oppression and apartheid really did not change all that much. Then going forward to Obama's election and the tremendous hope that you felt when finally a black president was elected, and not only that, I mean a black president who said he was a community organizer and one who organized an incredible ground operation that he promised to keep alive, but shut down as soon as he got inaugurated. Talk about how your first, you know, your reaction to both of those, to the limits of freedom within those contexts and where that pushed you. [Zinzi] Yeah, so those were both hugely defining experiences for me. The latter, Obama, I was more sort of active in than the former because I was just very young when independence happened. But a huge topic of the book is hope and disillusionment, I should say. You know, the feeling that everything is about to happen and I've been accused sometimes in my personal life of celebrating too early because I'll say, oh, you know, everything's done, we won, so we don't have to worry about it anymore, and then only to later learn that there's still quite a lot more work to do. You know, when Obama was elected, I was fresh out of college, I was about 23, 24. And I had never witnessed a political movement be that successful. So to have something like that happen so early on in someone's life is something that should probably, if it hasn't already been studied, it feels very unique. I also, you know, I volunteered for him in sort of small capacity, and I had a lot of friends who, you know, uprooted their lives and went to work for him and that ended up defining a lot of their, you know, the latter part of their lives. And I think that gave me the idea that like anything was possible. And I think like a lot of people on the left, I had a lot of hope and optimism for the future the belief in progress. And maybe not enough of a realization of how really messy it would be. How messy progress, in fact, always is. And you know, obviously, I think people talk a lot about the disappointment of the Trump years and seeing the ugly side of our neighbors and our country and, you know, being disappointed by that. The larger disappointment, I think probably happened with Obama because I expected more. I think I had always read enough and known enough not to expect too much of this country. And particularly of the rich white members of this country and both. [Francesca] And how they police the borders of success. I mean, because, you know, when almost the first act that Barack Obama made was to appoint Goldman Sachs to be in charge of the economy, I understood at that moment that he was not going to be the hope and change candidate that he had promised to be. That his job was to represent progress, but not particularly institute progress. Real progress. So talk about what those limitations, I mean structural limitations, in your own evolution. Because you went from Afro-pessimism to having real hope when Obama was elected, then the disillusionment, and then you went to a deeper understanding, I think, going back to Orlando Patterson also, and the idea of racial capitalism. You write that at one point you could have called me an Afro-pessimist, that it offered an explanation for the persistence of anti-blackness, even after a black man had become president. And then you moved to a majority white rural community and you encountered white poverty in a way that you never had before. And you write that my old math was scrambled. How did you unscramble that math? [Zinzi] So, what I'm describing there, and Obama is really sort of a linchpin in this story. When I was younger, probably through college, was sort of under the sway of the Afro-pessimist belief that race and anti-blackness specifically is the primary organizing factor of society. Is that society is arrayed against black people, and that race, skin color, is permanent. That the way that the world has treated skin color is permanent, fixed, internationally and throughout time. And that essentially all events can be explained based on that factor, again, to be slightly reductive for the sake of conversation, but essentially that's sort of what it was. And there's some overlap with Afro-pessimism and black nationalism, but this sort of primary fixation on race and anti-blackness. And as time went on, and I grew, I just came to see things as being more complicated than that. As I would hope that most people would, however, you know, there's a really powerful incentive in our society to not see things the way that I see them now. And that sort of complicated way is that, you know, is that racial difference has always existed, that people have been exploited based on their race throughout history. But that exploitation has often and usually come as a result of capitalism, right? Black people were exploited because of their skin color in order to power, you know, the global economy. And in this country, the battles over slavery, the Civil War, they were not because of, you know, anti-black racism per se. Those were some of the lines along which they were drawn, but it was about the battle between two economic models, the Northern industrial model and the Southern slave-owning plantation model. And that these things happen together. And it is actually authentically productive to explain everything, you know, based on anti-blackness, even though it is an incredibly powerful force in our daily lives and particularly in American life. Obama's election and, you know, the way things played out over the course of his presidency was, it was an interesting kind of merging of two powerful forces, which is, you know, the sort of liberal, anti-racist vein of American society and capital and hyper-capital. Because you had a president who was elected, the first black president, who then joined together, as you said, with J.P. Morgan and all of the major banks and has continued to do that to this very day. When I moved to upstate New York, I was in the Hudson Valley before that, the Catskills, which is the time that I write about in that essay, I moved into a community. I was not on the bottom because of my race. I was on the top because of my class. And there were a lot of white people below me. And I had to reckon with what that looked like in my daily life. Did I encounter racism? Yes. But it was nothing as serious as what I saw some of the white people around me facing on a daily basis. And I was, I think, so close to it and so surrounded by it that I had to really question some of my earlier ideas and sort of foundational ideas. And then I was also in the position of a lot of people in my generation, which is that for a long time, I was downwardly mobile. And I had read Marx, I had read a lot of Marxist scholars in college, and I understood it, but it kind of made itself known in my life in a real way. And it sort of reshaped the way that I looked at everything. [Francesca] And so I think this is really important because there was a lot of idea in the Democratic Party that if you just took care of the problem of representation, that you would take care of the problem of inequality or repression or oppression or whatever. And yet there were others. And I've forgotten his last name, Adolfo. He's a black Marxist who really got in the middle of this debate by saying that, you know, class was the more salient lens and that race is part of it. And he got a lot of pushback on that basis. How do we integrate our understanding of the role that racism plays within the construct of a class-based capitalist society in a way that promotes a, solidarity, and b, diversity and honoring diversity? I mean, it seems to me the key is to understand what is particular and what is intersectional, to use a term that was actually formed by a black women's collective, which talks about race and class, talks about race and gender, talks about class and gender. It seems to me we need to have a clearer understanding of power so that instead of people fighting each other or just trying to keep things up at the surface, really trying to move things forward, we need to integrate these in a way that honors all pieces of it. Those are some of the things that reading your books, Inzy Klemens, and reading Freedom really made me think. [Zinzi] I'm glad that it did. And, you know, the situation you describe where, you know, around 2016 to, I guess, like the end of Biden, Democrats were always trying to get us to think representation first. And, you know, a lot of the American left was often kind of dismissed as racist and sexist. And these things were done completely intentionally, right? Like, this is no mistake. This is not just an earlier sort of version of thinking that we've evolved beyond. This was strategized by consultants, and it has been done always. And as a way to target left populist movements, right? So I wish I could say that, like, a lot of really smart people wrote articles and, like, the wider public read them and realized that they were wrong about everything that happened for the last 10 years. But really what happened is just that things got a lot worse. And it's brought a lot of people to a place where they're more open to politicians like Mamdani and the other candidates that have been elected recently. I am in Philadelphia right now. I am in a district that is represented by two Democratic socialists at the state and national level. And they're both people of color. I think the vast majority of the DSA candidates have won primaries or elections. They're not white. I think that kind of satisfyingly, some of this stuff is just, they're just winning. And unfortunately, we've had to get to a place where things are so bad that people who would have normally been turned off by an Indian American socialist politician are now just, you know, they're fed up. And you see, they don't mind some of the more radical things that she says. And, you know, I've had people say that to me. And, you know, it's helped that like, the left has just gotten good at winning. And that's, that's great. What a miracle that is. It really is. But, you know, a lot of young people in this country, a lot of people in DSA have been working steadily for the past decade to get to where they are now. I don't believe that we've seen the end of it. I hope that we haven't. But I think the answer to the problem is, is work. I think some of the work, the political organizing that people have done is amazing. There's been incredible organizing that happened even in the last few elections. What happened in Georgia? Something seems to be happening in Texas. In Florida, the victory that happened recently, I've been watching that really closely. Just miraculous things that have happened when people essentially continue to do the work that they've been doing for years. And they come into a moment where there is more possibility for what they're doing. I think one of the most powerful things that can happen in the next few years is that the people who have a hold on power now can just step aside. And make room for where the energy is. In reality, as a writer, our lives are tedious. And the work basically always looks the same. It is sitting down and writing and getting up when you feel totally hopeless and awful about yourself and sitting down and doing it again and again. That will never change. It's just that sometimes the world is ready to listen to you. [Francesca] Yeah, and I think that's something that you really stress in your book, in Freedom. You had a phrase that you heard growing up in South Africa, Aluta kontinua, the struggle continues. It seems to me that that's where freedom lies, doesn't it? The ability to continue to struggle in solidarity with others and to let the barriers, the cages that we put ourselves into fall. You know, it really strikes me, this has been a theme more and more in the writers that I interview. People who are coming from all different places, who are writing fiction, who are writing essays, who are writing nonfiction, seem to be really moving toward one central point, which is that we're all in this together. Let's work together and let's find justice and freedom for everyone. That's good to know. It's a terrific book. It's been great to talk with you. Thank you. It was really nice to meet you, Francesca.